Film Theory: Star Wars, How The Mandalorian PROVES the Empire was Right!

14. nov.. 2020
1 543 790 Ganger

Check out Food Theory! ► bit.ly/2CdCooV
Don't miss a Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
With the return of The Mandalorian season 2 to Disney+, I felt it was about time to also return to a Star Wars theory. In a previous theory, I talked about how the Jedi could be construed as an 'evil' order. Today, I'm taking that kind of idea and flipping it to talk about the Empire itself! I think The Mandalorian provides us with even more clues that the Empire may not be as wrong in it's philosophy as we thought! How? Why? Well Theorists, make sure you Baby Yoda is somewhere safe because this is about to take a turn to the dark side...
0:38 - This is referencing two different studies citing two different percentages. It is not between 31% and 58%, it is both 31% and 58% percent results from the two studies.
Don't miss a Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
#StarWars #TheMandalorian #Mandalorian #BabyYoda #Jedi #Sith #DarthVader #Disney+ #Theory #FilmTheory #Matpat
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get Your 30 Day Free Trial Now ► share.epidemicsound.com/TheFilmTheorists
MORE FILM THEORIES
Rick's True CRIME! | Rick and Morty ►► bit.ly/2MVhP2W
Will MORTY KILL RICK?! ►► bit.ly/2qKFFFV
How PICKLE RICK Functions! ►►► bit.ly/2JvU4fT
Blair Witch's SECRET DANGER! ► bit.ly/2qhmv7a
Ariel & Hercules Are RELATED?! ► bit.ly/32WnVWi
Credits:
Writer: Matthew Patrick and Justin Kuiper
Editor: Tyler Mascola, Pedro Freitas, and Dan "Cybert" Seibert
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

Kommentarer
  • At least when the first order happens the Jedi were like, at least good people

    Luis FelipeLuis Felipe17 minutter siden
  • The Tarkin doctrine sounds a lot like communism to me

    Minecrafter 0Minecrafter 02 timer siden
  • Darth Vader was a jobs creator! Look at all the people employed on the Death Star!

    Cobra CommanderCobra Commander2 timer siden
  • Remember, history is written by the winners

    Minecrafter 0Minecrafter 02 timer siden
  • EMPIRE 4 LIFE!!

    Moses TrevinoMoses Trevino2 timer siden
  • In Luke’s defense the Ewoks were planning to cook and eat him and his friends...

    zijuiy wttuyzijuiy wttuy4 timer siden
  • Film theory making excuses for fascism...

    DrudenfuszDrudenfusz7 timer siden
    • Well it's not the real world so?

      Legate RemeLegate Reme6 timer siden
  • Not sure I agree with that argument about slavery 🤔

    Directors ChoiceDirectors Choice7 timer siden
  • Me: thinks this is a theory about the child Mattpatt: THINK AGAIN!!

    Eric MyersEric Myers7 timer siden
    • "Thanks to today's sponser,The Galactic Empire."

      zijuiy wttuyzijuiy wttuy4 timer siden
  • 3:28 lol he's got backwards hands

    Sanji! The Cigarette Smoking SimpSanji! The Cigarette Smoking Simp7 timer siden
  • Let's say both sides are ideologic and misusing other people for it.

    Y. A.Y. A.8 timer siden
  • Next time : The combine were the heros

    Frankie PersonFrankie Person8 timer siden
  • I too am a big fan of literal facism

    Ari OkuboAri Okubo8 timer siden
  • #Thankmas #CallToAction noworld.info/video/video/vJivlNarpbiy0NU.html

    Orna GavinOrna Gavin10 timer siden
  • OMG TECHNOBLADE WAS RIGHT GOVERMENTS ARE BAD!!!!

    Random VIDS!! KRandom VIDS!! K10 timer siden
  • Legit just finished watching the clone wars animated series, there were too many moments when the jedi order refused help or salvation to the neutral or dying worlds, because coruscant was more important to them, ironically enough with everyone but the nobility and the jedi living in near poverty. From what happens in the first scenes of SOLO, we easily see that the empire ain't too bad as a functioning government. Yeah they had their moments, but the republic wasn't even close to the level of development that the Empire had.

    Zachry BinksZachry Binks10 timer siden
  • "Once more the Sith will rule the Galaxy and we shall have... peace."

    Cultural SugarCultural Sugar10 timer siden
  • the mandalorian seems like lockdown from transformers age of extinction

    Wade PetersWade Peters10 timer siden
  • USSR was also great for some poorer regions that totally collapsed with USSR and are still doing very badly. This doesn't make USSR good though.

    Timo425Timo42511 timer siden
  • I normally love film theory, but honestly, a full fledged defense of the fascist empire shoulda been called into question before the video was posted. Why not just stick to, “the republic was bad”. We all coulda done without the empire is good bit.

    A.D McCormackA.D McCormack11 timer siden
  • YAY!

    Pre abrahamPre abraham11 timer siden
  • Dude, don't even try to use anything from the sequels in your videos, we all know that they never happened.

    Echo 18Echo 1812 timer siden
  • I didn’t even watch this, but I can tell it didn’t age well with the reveal of why the Gideon wants baby yoda. Not gonna say though because spoilers

    JjjaceJjjace12 timer siden
  • "Thanks to today's sponser,The Galactic Empire."

    GodfatherGodfather14 timer siden
    • Can't wait to r/whoosh Just kidding I copied someone else's comment.. Hohohohohohohoho

      GodfatherGodfather14 timer siden
  • is Star wars not more about the chaotic good rebels fighting lawful evil empire, Both sides have Their positive and negatives Both Missing the point of how to provide for all its people. It's great that certain characters talked about bringing balance to the force But understood it to mean completely the opposite.

    Chris GriffinChris Griffin16 timer siden
  • About the beginning, I had a project in my high school psychology class where we diagnose a fictional character with a personality disorder. It was really fun

    Ross WalenciakRoss Walenciak16 timer siden
  • The war didn't end wih the battle of Endor, it did with the battle of Jakku.

    Happy_97Happy_9716 timer siden
  • Btw, the Mandalorian didn't take place anywhere near the time of the original star wars movies. Yoda was still very young, so there is no way there was 800 years between the movies. The Mandalorian took place WAAAAAY before any of this happened

    Luke the GreatestLuke the Greatest16 timer siden
  • The book Tarkin is not Legends...

    BreadZBreadZ18 timer siden
  • The empire was a better government... unless you are a Wookie or you live on a planet in the outlying system. Admittedly, if you live in the outlying system you are screwed under either government. Just saying with the deals the empire made with the Hut clan on several occasions the outlying system wasn't really much better off.

    John O'KeefeJohn O'Keefe18 timer siden
  • Makes sense, innit. Unless you take freedom into account.

    Frenz ScivolaFrenz Scivola19 timer siden
  • This isn’t well known by non hardcore Star Wars fans, but in legends the Jedi were the ones who started fighting the sith, the sith just wanted to be left alone and study the dark side.

    LookieLookie20 timer siden
  • Since watching star wars in my teens I always though the empire to be the good guys... yes there supreme leaders evil but I can see that there was more prosperity and sucess under the empire then the republic... just my thoughts...

    Psycho CrowPsycho Crow23 timer siden
  • Luke convincing the ewoks was so they would not be eaten by them. As for the everyday citizen being happy under the empires rule you forget about all the people they forced into slavery.

    Eddie RichardsonEddie Richardson23 timer siden
  • Also that’s how the empire got its solders not by making clones or by stealing young kids but by winning the people in there trust

    The ShadowThe ShadowDag siden
  • Because of this video, I now believe in the Sith. F**k those rebel scum...

    Soffian ShariffSoffian ShariffDag siden
  • 0:33 i disagree with that but they aren't the good guys either, the Jedi are extremist and when you go to the extreme of anything you tend to start going wrong and to make matters worse they are an extremist religious group that as part of their training teaches there people to hate others based on their beliefs and are heavily armed i mean what could possibly go wrong with that idea?

    permeuspermeusDag siden
  • 13:28 MatPat’s clearly never played Ewok Hunt on Battlefront II😂

    Cole DysonCole DysonDag siden
  • So... uh... are we just going to ignore the entirety of Star Wars Rebels? In this show alone, the Empire - Burned a mining planet for resources - Enslaved it's inhabitants into the workforce - Enslaved the Wookies - Add puppet leaders to betray their own people - Kidnap children - Restrict output/press - Torture captives - Use a Jedi Master's CORPSE as a way to lure the enemy - Takes Hostages - Bombs an innocent city - Indoctrination of minors The entire show is about showing that the empire is evil, and not redeemable in any way (aside from being efficient) The empire is only good in the same sense that Germany was "good" in WWII which everyone knows is not the case. The Imperial troops are called "Stormtroopers."

    Joseph DarvishJoseph DarvishDag siden
  • HEY MATPAT! So I have an idea for your fourth channel (to complete the little circle thing in all of your channel logos, food theory being the third one). It could be Life Theory, involving things in the real world. Things like “why do people enjoy __ so much?” You could get I to more science and math stuff, because both science and math are part of real life. Personally, if you did make this, I would love for you to explain why schools teach us stuff we might not even need in the real world. I think that’s a question we all want the answer to. Well, I doubt you’ll actually be reading this comment, but I’m gonna do my best to get it in your sight.

    Vanilla YTVanilla YTDag siden
  • That’s why I am an authoritarian

    Tommy GannettTommy GannettDag siden
    • @Emily An nah I’ve been an authoritarian for a while as in I’m a absolute monarchist and a right wing socialist

      Tommy GannettTommy Gannett18 timer siden
    • Cool...super loved it?

      Emily AnEmily AnDag siden
  • Democracy: The God that Failed

    AwsometimeAwsometimeDag siden
    • Real life example of this is Gaddafi

      Emily AnEmily AnDag siden
  • The Empire is literally Conunissum, sometimes good, some time bad ._.

    TheDonaldMcRonaldTheDonaldMcRonaldDag siden
  • What I told you was true, from a certain point of view. You're going to find that many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.

    Josh HsojJosh HsojDag siden
  • In legends, the empire was built to face the inevitable yuuzhan vong invasion, palpatine discovered the Outlanders plan for invasion of the galactic republic and decided the old republic was too weak to fight off an invasion of that size, he was right, the new republic nearly lost that war it took a pact with the emperial remnant to stop the invasion. So yeah palpatine was right, but that was the old canon

    slaymaster999slaymaster999Dag siden
  • The new republic only exists for 5 years so they are still building it up.

    yodathanyodathanDag siden
  • Right so din djarin has to believe that the empire improves every planet it touches. But take in mind that when the empire touched mandalore they killed everybody and stole all theyer resources. Also known as the great purge

    yodathanyodathanDag siden
  • the new republics biggest failure probably comes from the fact that instead of taking over the empire, they just destroyed it. the empire had a huge advantage when it started because it simply took over the republic and rebuilt it. but the new republic tried starting from scratch, which was stupid.

    XXDag siden
  • but but sith evil therefore empire evil, jedi good therefore the new republic and old republic is better, duh. ofc I'm being sarcastic.

    XXDag siden
  • You’re ignoring the: -Wookie Slavery -Ewok Genocide -Tacking and Killing of all Jedi, mostly children -everything about inquisitors -sadistic rule over lothal, and every other city -Project Cinder -Destruction of Jedha and scarif It’s just a authoritarian dictatorship, it’s not good

    Ben SegneriBen SegneriDag siden
  • 1:10 all classic symptoms of teenagers. I mean seriously, you're comparing a what 10 year old to someone whos like 15-17? also anakin is the way he is because he was constantly called the chosen one, and how he was going to bring balance to the force. yet from his perspective, not being a jedi master was the council looking down on him. and in an ironic sense, his actions only proved that he was an immature teen who wasn't ready to become a master.

    XXDag siden
  • Why does this sound familiar?

    Lilly McAffeeLilly McAffeeDag siden
  • The most painful part of the sequel book series was the written astonishment at how badly they are doing and how they are literally recreating the conditions that the empire took over from. Also MatPat, would you willing to do videos on topics on Dune? Like how the water reclaiming still-suits might be feasible or is it really possible for humans to become like biological computers.

    Joseph DellavecchiaJoseph DellavecchiaDag siden
  • The Empire did nothing wrong.

    Scourge 64Scourge 64Dag siden
  • Mattpat you are correct long live the empire

    Aidan SouthworthAidan SouthworthDag siden
  • From matpats thoughts about this whole thing Empire:”standard” Sith:”ceaseless destroyers that want to take everything” Jedi:”unrelenting warring perfectionists”

    I̶N̶F̶I̶N̶I̶T̶Y̶ Z̶e̶r̶0̶I̶N̶F̶I̶N̶I̶T̶Y̶ Z̶e̶r̶0̶Dag siden
  • Real life example of this is Gaddafi

    IngagiIngagiDag siden
  • You forgot about the Wookies, which are slaved, as you see in "The force unleashed" :)

    Markus MayrMarkus MayrDag siden
  • The empire and the ewoks were never on good terms. As soon as they landed on endor the ewoks attacked them.

    a generic accounta generic accountDag siden
  • Clone army. Literally made out of child slave soldiers, with eugenics sprinkled on top, led by bung of nepotistic Heaven's Gate space-wizards.

    Dark. DukeDark. DukeDag siden
    • Clone Amy ordered by the Sith = Empire

      Jet BlackJet Black6 timer siden
  • They also murdered children for being sensitive to the force- Rebels shows that.

    Daniel GuerinDaniel GuerinDag siden
  • Wookies beg to differ

    Sir. GamerSir. GamerDag siden
  • dave filoni and sam witwer would have a field day dismantling you lmao

    David TillmanDavid TillmanDag siden
  • 91.610 user like it and would join the empire and want ''Peace'' 3738 user dislike the video and want death and chaos

    GrodaradosGrodaradosDag siden
  • This topic of the empire's rule is even further explained in the starwars comics, directly showing the (more or less ok) rule of the Empire. I forgot the name, but a great example was Agent of the Empire, or something like that.

    A SA SDag siden
  • The fact that MatPat thinks he's just a joe shmo youtuver is funny

    Joseph JonesJoseph JonesDag siden
  • Popcorn makes you stupid.

    Robin The God - Fake ASMR Is Being StupidRobin The God - Fake ASMR Is Being StupidDag siden
  • Psychiatry is retarded.

    Robin The God - Fake ASMR Is Being StupidRobin The God - Fake ASMR Is Being StupidDag siden
  • Mando: Will you train this baby? Ashoka: Haha, no *throws baby yoda off cliff* Directed by Jon Favreau

    The Candler KidsThe Candler KidsDag siden
  • Yeah starting to think you would be for another order that the empire was based on......and they have dances numbers too while marching, I know your theater background would be all for that.

    derek walzerderek walzerDag siden
  • FYI, "Tarkin" is considered canon. Any books that were written after the "Darth Maul: Son of Dathomir" comic mini-series are considered canon, including "Tarkin."

    Sir ZestoSir ZestoDag siden
  • Mad props for the Clerks reference.

    casey wilsoncasey wilsonDag siden
  • So the empire is not that great, but i do feel really bad for imperial stormtroopers. If you live on an imperial planet, you are practically forced to join the military, only to be choked by your master or have some laser-sword wielding maniac cut you up by the dozens, watching your friends get killed with the enemy not showing the slightest regret and even downright enjoying it.

    PJBobPJBobDag siden
  • So what you're saying is you like tyranny because they rule order with an inflexible hand, thus giving an appearance of peace?

    Alexander The RedAlexander The RedDag siden
  • "Think about how crazy that is" or just how comically in-cohesive the sequel trilogy was

    The SlangwhangerThe SlangwhangerDag siden
  • We govern are selves and the government comes in and helps. The truth of the matter is the government should only help protect it. Yes after a war things are a mess and you have everyone fighting to be in charge only way to make it work is the people on the planet taking care of themselves. Because the republic only wanted faithful followers though force and force leads to lazy people not willing to put in work. Know they have to work and volunteer to help protect themselves. Your argument is that the government should have all the power and make all the decisions. It should be up to the people and the people need to make decisions to help themselves. The truth is we are the best at helping ourselves and working together and when you only expect the government to protect you become selfish and stop thinking of helping. Your argument is the government should do it and let’s be honest no government is going to be as good as your neighbor or loved ones they give a crap

    rachel Crawfordrachel CrawfordDag siden
  • The difference between the empire and the new republic is that the empire was lawful evil and the new republic was chaotic good

    Jones KleidJones KleidDag siden
  • Just the entirety of the Star Wars: Rebels series proves you wrong but hey why not make another pointless video..........once again XD. No, but I love your content.

    patrick silveirapatrick silveiraDag siden
  • I'm the governor of illinois! I'm the governor of the milky way you peon

    Meekah SheMeekah SheDag siden
  • I think what we are missing here is that what are the hardest things to do in a movie is create a fully working political system and Lucas has done that to some extent

    Average ChipAverage ChipDag siden
  • 'they improved the outer rim!' What? All I see on Tatooine in the movies is the empire willingly working with the slave-driving, mafia-like Hutts. All they've done is put troops *on* Tatooine, and had them oppress the people there Sure, the Republic didn't help them, but they also didn't BURN THEIR FUCKING HOUSES, AUNTS AND UNCLES TO ASH

    thnkngthnkngDag siden
  • Pls make a Jurassic World Theory why... -There is a surprising scene where a SABER TOOTH Tiger fossil is showed, Not sure if Real or Fake -There are many theories about what will happen in Jurassic World 3/Dominion that show some information but not that clear So pls make a JP3 Theory lord matpat

    Djibou GamingDjibou GamingDag siden
  • Trueee

    ParisAC9ParisAC92 dager siden
  • "Admittedly that was a pretty huge, evil thing" Kinda like nuking two cities full of civilians?

    Beau SeymourBeau Seymour2 dager siden
  • 14:34 until he remembers what happened to Mandalore...

    Eclipse 6344Eclipse 63442 dager siden
  • 5:39 Guess someone should have told the republic "Winning is easy, young man. Governing's harder." Probably the only one who thought of the Hamilton reference tho lol

    Bernice HeeBernice Hee2 dager siden
  • I always knew Anakin had an actual good reason for joining the Empire

    Human BeingHuman Being2 dager siden
  • The imperial logo looks like a unified galaxy if you look at it right

    John McHaleJohn McHale2 dager siden
  • The Empire made alien slavery legal, so...

    A Knight BetrayedA Knight Betrayed2 dager siden
  • If Kotor/Swtor taught me anything it's that the Empire and the Sith are two very separate entities that kind of just work with and around each other because they share similar goals

    Daniel MachulkaDaniel Machulka2 dager siden
  • Matpat, have you seen Star Wars Rebels? Have you seen how much destruction the empire had done? Did you forget the slavery of Mandalore and other planets? How about the growing racism against non-human? Also, Vader never really had any loyalty to the empire. He planned to overthrow the emperor and achieve the original intent of the jedi, to bring peace, freedom, justice, and security to the people. Emperor Sidious only wanted power to himself. He did anyting to expand his power.

    Irza LiandoIrza Liando2 dager siden
  • will you zombies stop liking this guy

    TzerTzer2 dager siden
    • the sombies are coming

      TzerTzer2 dager siden
    • good guys are actually bad and the bad guys are good.

      Emily AnEmily An2 dager siden
  • The only problem though is that the lore doesn’t support this idea. Take the CANON book Lost Stars. We see the disparity between Core Worlds and Outer Rim worlds. We see the Empire’s conscription tactics. And we see that they rule primarily through fear and manipulation. The only people that are in the Empire are either too afraid to leave or have been obviously brainwashed. And this book followed two Imperials, one of whom even defected to the Rebels!

    Zachary AllenZachary Allen2 dager siden
    • Will now call this channel Film Fact

      Emily AnEmily An2 dager siden
  • But I mean the new information about what they wanted to do with Baby Yoda is sick.

    ClucklesCluckles2 dager siden
  • *cough cough* United states

    JayLoungerYTJayLoungerYT2 dager siden
  • When Film Theory pulls on loose threads like a MAGA person pulling on loose threads that COVID 19 isn’t real.

    Aaron AlejoAaron Alejo2 dager siden
  • There are no good guys...

    jack willjack will2 dager siden
  • I'm slowly starting to like the politics and military aspects of starwars more than the Jedi and sith part... It's very interesting

    SilverFruit14SilverFruit142 dager siden
  • *alderaan disliked the video*

    Antonio ArredondoAntonio Arredondo2 dager siden
  • In a cut scene from a New Hope Biggs mentions to Luke about the Empire nationalized commerce and the central systems, and it would not be long before the Empire takes over Uncle Owen's farm. Reducing him to a tenant farmer slaving away for the glory of the Empire.

    Joe DumasJoe Dumas2 dager siden
NOworld